Friday night, an amazing thing happened at swanky Williamsburg bar/restaurant Dressler. I was with my friends Nicholas and Rebecca. Bartender/friend Jim was serving beverages.
We were talking about pizza, just talking pizza, and Rebecca was asked to name her favorite two-topping combination. Before she could respond, I boldly claimed Nicholas and I could guess what it is.
We each got to ask one question about the combination.
I went first: “Is it a classic combination?” Rebecca stated that while not a classic combo in the classic sense of the word, it’s not unknown, either.
Nicholas wasn’t sure what to ask. “You could ask anything,” Rebecca said. “For example, you could ask, ‘Is one of the toppings meat?’”
“Is one of the toppings meat?” Nicholas asked.
“Yes.”
Now, there are many little details to this story. Give me a call if you need all the _________ filled in.
The important thing is, Nicholas and I knew what was at stake: if we got it right on the first shot, it would be amazing. Second try would be respectable, but not amazing. If we missed the mark entirely, we would not be legends, we would not transcend time, we would be forgotten, we would be losers with no skills.
Nicholas and I brainstormed and discussed the matter in great detail for about a half hour, at which point Rebecca began to grow anxious.
After stepping out for a solo smoke, she cut to the chase: “What’s your first guess?”
“Pepperoni and olives!” Nicholas proclaimed.
A smile spread across Rebecca’s face as she whispered, amazed, “That’s right.”
Shittttt, sonnnnnnnnn.
Before I knew what was happening, my arms were up in the air like Robert Horry after he hit the game-winning three against Sacramento in the 2002 Western Conference Finals.
It was amazing. What were the odds?
All I could do was shout (repeatedly), “That was amazing!” Nicholas was laughing joyously. Rebecca was properly impressed. It was so amazing. Everyone knew it was amazing.
The greatest part was, Nicholas and I had just done something amazing, and we knew it, right then and there. We weren’t looking back on a moment and reminiscing, “Remember that? That was amazing.” No. We knew it’d be amazing if we succeeded, and then we succeeded, and it was amazing.
I felt like a champion. I felt like a mixture of Jordan, Duncan, Gretzky, and Big Papi.
Dirt Off Your Shoulder should’ve immediately blared over the speakers. It played in my mind.
And we didn’t even need the second guess. Second guess? What second guess? Oh, did we get two guesses? I guess we didn’t realize, because we only needed one.
It was a walk-off homer. Game over. Bottom of the ninth, down by one, man on base, home run, game fucking over. Like Kirk Gibson in 1988. Walk-off. Time to trot around the bases.
My only regret is not taking a victory lap around Dressler.
I thought Jim was going to give us drinks on the house. I’m not sure why that didn’t happen. Probably an oversight amidst the cacophony.
It was amazing. Truly amazing.
How many two topping combos with at least one meat are there? What are the odds of guessing the exact right combo?
And we did it.
Amazing.